Traveling to Shelter Island for the first time from NYC over July 4th weekend- not sure if I need a car. It's meant to be a relaxing weekend away from the city/tourists- so not looking to do much, beach during the day and out to dinner/drinks at night. Do I need a car? Getting mixed opinions from friends. Are there any rental cars on Shelter Island?
Can anyone give me advice on the best way to get from central New York to Shelter Island ? I WONT have a car. Thanks.